Hello, Lykkers! Childhood tales like Peter Pan have enchanted generations, but as we grow, we often notice the flaws hidden within them.

Disney’s 1953 animated Peter Pan brought the magic of Neverland to life but also included troubling elements that haven’t aged well. Enter filmmaker David Lowery with Peter Pan & Wendy, a reimagining that polishes the classic while addressing its outdated aspects.

A Bold, New Wendy

At the heart of this retelling is Wendy Darling, portrayed brilliantly by Ever Anderson. Gone is the passive girl who simply mothers the Lost Boys. This Wendy is spirited, independent, and ready to take control of her own narrative.

When Peter Pan (Alexander Molony) sweeps her away to Neverland, she challenges him, even exclaiming, “I-don’t even know if I-want to be a mother!” It’s a refreshing departure that redefines her role in the story and adds depth to her character.

A Layered Captain Hook

Captain Hook also undergoes a fascinating transformation. Jude Law shines as the tormented pirate, haunted by a tragic backstory and his fear of time’s relentless march. Lowery’s knack for exploring emotional depth breathes new life into this iconic villain, making him as compelling as he is menacing.

A Visual Feast

Visually, Peter Pan & Wendy pays homage to the original while carving its own identity. Lowery and cinematographer Bojan Bazelli craft a stunning Neverland with brooding skies, dramatic shadows, and vibrant jewel tones.

However, some creative choices fall flat. For instance, the “Tinkervision” effect—Tinkerbell’s blurred, jittery perspective—lacks impact. Yara Shahidi’s Tinkerbell is also toned down, missing the mischievous spark that once defined her.

Exploring Themes of Growth

Lowery and co-writer Toby Halbrooks use the extra screen time to delve into meaningful themes. Wendy’s bittersweet journey reflects the joys and fears of growing up, while Captain Hook’s backstory offers a poignant commentary on regret and loss. Yet, in emphasizing these themes, some beloved elements—like the feisty mermaids and Tiger Lily (played by Cree actress Alyssa Wapanatahk)—feel underdeveloped.

A Balancing Act

The film raises an intriguing question: how much can you change a classic while keeping its essence intact? With its modern updates and nostalgic nods, Peter Pan & Wendy feels like Theseus’s ship—a mix of old and new. Some elements shine, while others fall short, leaving viewers to decide if this reimagining captures the magic of Neverland.

Ultimately, Peter Pan & Wendy offers a thoughtful retelling for today’s audience. It may not replace the original in our hearts, but it’s a worthwhile journey into the timeless tale of never growing up.